Discredited Draft Review

Last night was our second annual Discredited Fantasy Baseball draft. I'm posting the results here for people to vote on who drafted the best. I'm particularly interested because of the twelve teams, six were drafted by robots. We'll see if teams drafted with the heart and grit only possessed by humans are better than ones drafted by cold and heartless spreadsheets.

As a reminder, it's a saber-friendly roto league. Offensive categories: OBP, SLG, R, RBI, Net SB. Pitching categories: QS, WHIP, K, ERA, SV. Teams start four OF, one extra IF, one UTIL, and can have 9 total pitchers of any kind. The teams are listed in the order they drafted.

Team 1 Team 2 Team 3
(1) Albert Pujols (2) Troy Tulowitzki (3) Miguel Cabrera
(24) Giancarlo Stanton (23) Cliff Lee (22) Jose Reyes
(25) Matt Holliday (26) Felix Hernandez (27) Mark Teixeira
(48) Stephen Strasburg (47) Dan Uggla (46) Josh Hamilton
(49) Zack Greinke (50) David Price (51) Nelson Cruz
(72) Kevin Youkilis (71) Mo Rivera (70) James Shields
(73) Shin-Soo Choo (74) Madison Bumgarner (75) Yovani Gallardo
(96) Billy Butler (95) Drew Storen (94) Daniel Hudson
(97) Rafael Betancourt (98) Joel Hanrahan (99) Ichiro Suzuki
(120) Buster Posey (119) Jason Heyward (118) Josh Beckett
(121) Brandon Beachy (122) Logan Morrison (123) Jordan Zimmerman
(144) Brandon League (143) Heath Bell (142) Dee Gordon
(145) Paul Goldschmidt (146) Nick Markakis (147) Anibal Sanchez
(168) Jason Kipnis (167) Gaby Sanchez (166) Justin Masterson
(169) Ted Lilly (170) Martin Prado (171) Ervin Santana
(192) Angel Pagan (191) Marco Scutaro (190) Kelly Johnson
(193) Sergio Santos (194) Geovany Soto (195) Jeff Francouer
(216) Matt Thornton (215) Kendrys Morales (214) Matt Capps
(217) Edwin Jackson (218) Brennan Boesch (219) Ryan Howard
(240) Frank Francisco (239) Russell Martin (238) Aaron Hill
(241) Johan Santana (242) Chad Billingsley (243) Chipper Jones
(264) Brett Anderson (263) Allen Craig (262) Kurt Suzuki
(265) Erik Bedard (266) Mark Buehrle (267) Omar Infante
(288) Rafael Furcal (287) Danny Valencia (286) Mike Adams

Team 4 Team 5 Team 6
(4) Matt Kemp (5) Ryan Braun (6) Jose Bautista
(21) Dustin Pedroia (20) Prince Fielder (19) Adrian Gonzalez
(28) Andrew McCutchen (29) Paul Konerko (30) Adrian Beltre
(45) Cole Hamels (44) Dan Haren (43) Jay Bruce
(52) Eric Hosmer (53) Jon Lester (54) Jimmy Rollins
(69) Asdrubal Cabrera (68) Michael Morse (67) Elvis Andrus
(76) David Ortiz (77) Brett Gardner (78) C.J. Wilson
(93) Matt Wieters (92) Josh Johnson (91) Jayson Werth
(100) Jeremy Hellickson (101) Michael Young (102) John Axford
(117) Chris Young (116) Alex Avila (115) Ubaldo Jimenez
(124) J.J. Hardy (125) Jhonny Peralta (126) Drew Stubbs
(141) Max Scherzer (140) Andrew Bailey (139) Gio Gonzalez
(148) Tim Hudson (149) Neftali Feliz (150) Andre Ethier
(165) Melky Cabrera (164) Scott Baker (163) Joakim Soria
(172) Jordan Walden (173) Dustin Ackley (174) Wandy Rodriguez
(189) Daniel Bard (188) Carlos Marmol (187) Neil Walker
(196) Clay Buchholz (197) Lucas Duda (198) Yadier Molina
(213) Ryan Dempster (212) Grant Balfour (211) Joe Nathan
(220) John Danks (221) Ike Davis (222) Javy Guerra
(237) Lonnie Chisenhall (236) Brandon Belt (235) Jonathan Sanchez
(244) Carlos Quentin (245) Derek Holland (246) Mark Trumbo
(261) Godon Beckham (260) Yonder Alonso (259) Jose Altuve
(268) Vance Worley (269) Brett Jackson (270) James Loney
(285) Johnny Giavotella (284) Chris Iannetta (283) Matt Gamel

Team 7 Team 8 Team 9
(7) Joey Votto (8) Robinson Cano (9) Carlos Gonzalez
(18) Justin Verlander (17) Hanley Ramirez (16) Curtis Granderson
(31) Ryan Zimmerman (32) David Wright (33) Jered Weaver
(42) Mike Napoli (41) Hunter Pence (40) CC Sabathia
(55) Matt Cain (56) Alex Gordon (57) Starlin Castro
(66) Carl Crawford (65) Aramis Ramirez (64) Brian McCann
(79) Alexei Ramirez (80) Alex Rodriguez (81) Rickie Weeks
(90) Matt Garza (89) Adam Jones (88) Ricky Romero
(103) Adam Dunn (104) Matt Latos (105) Michael Pineda
(114) Howard Kendrick (113) Chris Carpenter (112) Brian Wilson
(127) Huston Street (128) Miguel Montero (129) Yu Darvish
(138) J.J. Putz (137) Cory Luebke (136) Jose Valverde
(151) Doug Fister (152) Adam Lind (153) Nick Swisher
(162) Jaime Garcia (161) Torii Hunter (160) Carlos Lee
(175) Matt Joyce (176) Kyle Farnsworth (177) Colby Lewis
(186) Jason Kubel (185) Tim Stauffer (184) Emilio Bonifacio
(199) Yoenis Cespedes (200) Gavin Floyd (201) Daniel Murphy
(210) Chris Perez (209) Bud Norris (208) Danny Espinosa
(223) Justin Morneau (224) Alex Rios (225) Delmon Young
(234) J.P. Arencibia (233) Ricky Nolasco (232) Johnny Venters
(247) Sean Rodriguez (248) Jhoulys Chacin (249) Mitch Moreland
(258) Carlos Zambrano (257) Ian Desmond (256) Ivan Nova
(271) Alfonso Soriano (272) Jair Jurrjens (273) Salvador Perez
(282) Addison Reed (281) J.D. Martinez (280) Ryan Raburn

Team 10 Team 11 Team 12
(10) Roy Halladay (11) Jacoby Ellsbury (12) Evan Longoria
(15) Clayton Kershaw (14) Justin Upton (13) Ian Kinsler
(34) Tim Lincecum (35) Pablo Sandoval (36) Carlos Santana
(39) Ben Zobrist (38) Michael Bourn (37) Brett Lawrie
(58) Lance Berkman (59) Brandon Phillips (60) Craig Kimbrel
(63) Matt Moore (62) Shane Victorino (61) Jonathan Papelbon
(82) Adam Wainwright (83) Ian Kennedy (84) B.J. Upton
(87) Desmond Jennings (86) Chase Utley (85) Michael Cuddyer
(106) Carlos Beltran (107) Ryan Madson (108) Erick Aybar
(111) Joe Mauer (110) Corey Hart (109) Tommy Hanson
(130) Coco Crisp (131) Derek Jeter (132) Mark Reynolds
(135) Jason Motte (134) Shaun Marcum (133) Freddie Freeman
(154) Ryan Roberts (155) Hiroki Kuroda (156) Brandon Morrow
159) Josh Willingham (158) Johnny Cueto (157) Cameron Maybin
(178) Chris Sale (179) Brandon McCarthy (180) Jesus Montero
(183) Edwin Encarnacion (182) Stephen Drew (181) Sergio Romo
(202) Kenley Jansen (203) Carlos Pena (204) Mike Moustakas
(207) Colby Rasmus (206) Mike Minor (205) David Freese
(226) Jemile Weeks (227) Wilson Ramos (228) Tyler Clippard
(231) Chase Headley (230) Yunel Escobar (229) Brett Myers
(250) Mike Carp (251) Jim Johnson (252) Peter Bourjos
(255) Jason Bartlett (254) Francisco Cordero (253) Dexter Fowler
(274) Josh Collmenter (275) Austin Jackson (276) Jonathon Niese
(279) Jose Tabata (278) Alcides Escobar (277) Trevor Cahill

Vote in the comments.

Quantcast