Part one dealt with the pitchers. This part will focus on the position players, primarily the Mets, though I'll come back around to look at some splits and stuff for the Cubs batters at the end.
I'll rank the likely position players in decreasing wOBA:
OF Yoenis Cespedes (.287/.337/.604, .394): The Mets picked up Cespedes at the trade deadline, and in his two months with the team he's set the world on fire. He hit 17 HR in 57 games and struck out at a 21.7% clip, with only a 5.6% walk rate. He's a free swinger, it's safe to say. Despite being a RHH, he has actually hit righties better than lefties in his career (.348 to .337). When you see that .337 OBP you feel pretty good, but that .604 SLG erases that pretty quick (dying laughing). Defensively, he's an above average LF and below average CF.
OF Michael Conforto (.270/.335/.506, .359): Conforto was the tenth overall pick in last year's draft, and rocketed to the majors this year in a season that saw an absurd wealth of rookie debuts. He got the call-up following months of injury-riddled ineffectiveness by Michael Cuddyer and did a solid job, posting 2.1 WAR in 56 games with solid defense in LF. The Mets have largely shielded him from facing lefties (just 15 PAs) which might account for his relatively high wOBA. Given the Cubs lack of lefty starters, I'm guessing we'll see a lot of him, with Cuddyer pinch hitting if the Cubs bring in Wood or Clay Dick to face him.
1B Lucas Duda (.244/.352/.486, .359): Duda is ptobably the most underrated Mets hitter out there, and one of the rare non-pitcher members of the Wandy Rodriguez Hall of Fame. He posted a -0.4 WAR over his first four seasons, then posted a .253/.349/.481 line in 2014, his age 28 season, clubbing thirty home runs. He followed it up with an almost identical season this year, though bafflingly enough with only 73 RBI. It's a dumb stat, but given how crazy this Mets offense was this year you figure he would be one of the centerpieces. Fangraphs is not a big fan of his defense, though the metrics themselves (DRS/UZR) seem to think he's pretty average.
3B David Wright (.289/.379/.484, .359): I don't think anyone was more relieved than Wright when the whole Matt Harvey pitch count/innings thing blew up in the media last month, as well as Cespedes's offensive explosion. The longtime Mets franchise player, he always gets the most scrutiny from the extremely rational NY media whenever things were going on but now he's just a guy on a team full of good players. He missed most of the season due to what was initially a hamstring injury, and later tuned out to be a spinal injury (scary stuff). When in the lineup he hit just fine, though small sample sizes abound. He's a decent defender at 3B.
OF Curtis Granderson (.259/.364/.457, .357): I was shocked when I saw in one of the NLDS games that Granderson hit 26 HRs this year – it goes to show how little attention I pay to the AL that I forgot his 40+ HR years with the Yankees. He hit 43 and drove in 106 in 2012 for only 2.7 WAR, Joe Carter would be proud. He hit 20 homers last year for the Mets in what was a largely disappointing season, especially defensively. This year the metrics seem to think he's about average with the glove, and his hitting rate stats all rose about the same as the 40 point rise in his BABIP from last season. He's cut down on his strikeout rate in a big way compared to his Yankees years as well.
C Travis d'Arnaud (.268/.340/.485, .355): d'Arnaud spent a lot of time on the DL this year, including a two month stretch starting in April with a broken hand and another month long stretch in June-July. When he was in the lineup he produced just fine though – his stats prorated to a full starting catcher's season is around 4.5 WAR. He finished off the season ice cold, however, putting up a .143/.222/.163 line from Sep 15 to the end of the regular season. He went oh-fer in all of the NLDS games except for that crazy 13-7 game, where he had three hits and a homer. That might even have been a below average performance in that game (dying laughing).
2B Daniel Murphy (.281/.322/.449, .325): To get on an Old Hoss Radbourn rant for a second, there are too many goddamned Murphys in this league. There's this guy, and David Murphy (who I always confuse for each other, if not think they are one person) and former Cubs great Donnie Murphy running around. This is almost as bad as the Demariyus/Julius Thomas 80/88 jersey thing with the Broncos last year. This Murphy is a contact hitter who rarely walks and strikes out less than average, and has a soupçon of pop. Most of his value seems to lie in his versatility, though he's not a particularly good defender at any position.
1B/OF Michael Cuddyer (.259/.309/.391, .306): Cuddyer posted a .414 wOBA with the A's last year in injury-limited time, which was enough to get 2/21 from the Mets this offseason. He repeated the injury-limited part, but not the wOBA, coming in at replacement level on the year. His already low walk rate dropped to 5.9% and he started striking out 50% more often. Safe to say it's not quite what the Mets were expecting. It looks like he's more or less a platoon guy now, so will probably start tonight.
SS Wilmer Flores (.263/.295/.408, .304): Flores is another contact guy who is largely meh with the bat, but is mostly there for his glove. I remember last season when Mets fans feted him as the first competent SS to come out of their system in forever, and competent is probably about his ceiling. As awful as that Ruben Tejada injury was, I'm surprised at how much sentiment I remember seeing/thinking I saw about the Mets being screwed with him out – they're pretty much the exact same player on paper. Tejada's line this year was .261/.338/.350 with a .303 wOBA. Better at getting on base, but a lot less pop.
CF Juan Lagares (.259/.289/.358, .280): Lagares is a terrible hitter but a plus plus defender in CF. His numbers didn't look as good this year but I'd take more stock in the 45 runs above replacement he put up in the previous two years combined. He might get a start or two, but we'll defnitely see him as a defensive replacement in any game the Mets are winning.
The Cubs are facing a lot of RHPs this series, so if they succeed it's probably going to mean big serieses from Schwarber and Rizzo, and maybe Montero or Coghlan, if he manages to find his way into the lineup. With Soler hitting as hot as he is right now, it's tough luck for him. Here's a rundown of all the Cubs regulars' wOBA splits this year
vs LHP
- Baez (.462) (20 PA)
- Rizzo (.383)
- Fowler (.376)
- Jackson (.350) (30 PA)
- Bryant (.348)
- Montero (.342)
- Soler (.318)
- Castro (.283)
- NORF (.264)
- Russell (.236)
- Schwarber (,217)
- Ross (.176)
- Coghlan (.172)
vs RHP
- Schwarber (.407)
- Rizzo (.384)
- Bryant (.377)
- Coghlan (.355)
- Montero (.326)
- NORF (.325)
- Russell (.324)
- Fowler (.320)
- Soler (.311)
- Castro (.290)
- Baez (.265)
- Ross (.237)
Random news and thoughts
Syndergaard was just confirmed as the Mets game 2 starter, and Matz will go in game 4. He might be available out of the pen this weekend as well.
OV Podcast #10 is in the books and on the web. I mentioned in the pod that I have the Cubs in 6 as my prediction.
Quintin Berry replaced Addison Russell on the roster for the NLCS. I hope he can come back before the World Series, if the Cubs manage to get there.
To-day's base ball squadrons
Cubs
- Fowler
- Schwarber
- Bryant
- Rizzo
- Castro
- Soler
- Baez
- Ross
- Lester
Metropolitans
- Granderson
- Wright
- Murphy (?!)
- Cespedes
- d'Arnaud
- Cuddyer
- Flores
- Lagares
- Harvey
Comments
IIRC Murphy was a big NLDS hero.
Hot hand I guess.
Suburban kidQuote Reply
(dying laughing)
WaLiQuote Reply
Yeah, serieses.
Suburban kidQuote Reply
Suburban kid,
But which one!!
#toomanygoddamnedMurphs
WaLiQuote Reply
David Price just blew a 3-0 lead in the 7th.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Rizzo the Rat,
Rally started by a non-error error (goins).
Suburban kidQuote Reply
Fucking Blue Jays
dmick89Quote Reply
At the same time, not so sure I want to face that offense in WS when they decide to wake up, so, uh, go Royals.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Suburban kidQuote Reply
Suburban kid,
I think I was pretty thrilled when they hired Manny Ramirez.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Yeah, that makes some sense, but I’d like the Cubs to beat an actual MLB team if they’re going to win the World Series. The royals remind me of a very good Little League team.
dmick89Quote Reply
dmick89,
Haha I think they match up well with just about any of these teams but I’d prefer a higher odds of winning 🙂
Rice CubeQuote Reply
My dream would be the Cubs beat the Jays and Rizzo gives a bat-flip for the ages (he’s been rehearsing for that moment, after all).
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Hey look the tying run is at the plate.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Walkoff bat flip
Rice CubeQuote Reply
But, yes, I do think the Cubs’ chances are better against Kansas City.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
David Ross starting really annoys me.
Dusty talks to the security people at Citi to get the scoop on Harvey. (dying laughing)
dmick89Quote Reply
dmick89,
So glad MLB.TV doesn’t have any pregame.
Suburban kidQuote Reply
Alright jabronis, let’s do this!
fueledbyvinylQuote Reply
dmick89,
Yes. It wouldn’t bother me if Maddon would pinch-hit him should a high-leverage situation arrive, but we know he won’t.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
With the Lester/Ross battery, the Cubs have two soft spots in the lineup (even relative to their positions).
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
I hope David Ross retires after the the season.
dmick89Quote Reply
dmick89,
Supposedly he’s a great clubhouse/team chemistry guy. Maybe they could promote him to coach?
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Rizzo the Rat,
That’s fine. They could also use him as Clark the Cub.
dmick89Quote Reply
So…this apparently happened while I wasn’t paying attention.
http://www.cc.com/video-clips/o6obqg/the-daily-show-with-trevor-noah-an-illinois-mayor-gets-parodied-on-twitter
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Early deficit…pretty sure Cubs score more than one run this game.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Rice Cube,
That’s exactly what berselius said in game 1 against the Cardinals.
dmick89Quote Reply
????????????????????
berseliusQuote Reply
We really need like buttons.
MylesQuote Reply
dmick89,
He was eventually right later on in the series.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Fixed for valley girl accent.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Suburban kidQuote Reply
Damn—I was so looking forward to Ross proving us all wrong.
ceruleanQuote Reply
It’d be kinda cool if they make Harvey work the second time through the order.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Perkins,
Just like…. a little even.
JoshQuote Reply
Now with only 4 strikeouts?
umbraQuote Reply
This bar is playing “Beth” by KISS. Oddly matches the Cubs offense tonite.
uncle daveQuote Reply
Why are half the seats behind home empty?
Wenningtons Gorilla CockQuote Reply
I want to see Harvey start nibbling. Work that count Dex.
ceruleanQuote Reply
6 pitch AB from Fowler is a start, at least.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Fair weather fans.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Damnit, Flores.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Maybe Schwarber scared him off his game with that head-hunting laser.
ceruleanQuote Reply
With the offensive black holes in Ross and Lester and Soler in cold weather, not feeling bullish about the Cubs’ scoring chances.
PerkinsQuote Reply
This is all because dmick89 forgot to ask for early runs.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Mid-game runs, please.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
So maybe Joe should have started Arrieta today.
PerkinsQuote Reply
I think they need him tomorrow.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Perkins,
I think Lester is doing fine, just not getting run support so far and only really one big mistake. I don’t think the Cubs will be shut out today.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Lester looks great. Would be nice if the offense could do something.
dmick89Quote Reply
I do.n’t either.
MylesQuote Reply
Ouchy.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Castro!
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Yes!
PerkinsQuote Reply
YES STARLIN
berseliusQuote Reply
Schwarber has had a good AB and that is literally it so far this game. Harvey looks good but we look baaaaaf so far. Could change.
MylesQuote Reply
False.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Asking for runs really works!
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
A spark.
ceruleanQuote Reply
CASSIE!
uncle daveQuote Reply
You fucking idiot
MylesQuote Reply
You misquoted me.
MylesQuote Reply
Gotta hope Javy can cash in this run.
PerkinsQuote Reply
SHUT YOU RIGHT UP
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Damn it.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Why are they challenging Cespedes?
JoshQuote Reply
Goddamnit, have they not learned not to run on Cespedes?
PerkinsQuote Reply
Don’t run on La potencia.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
What the fuck with that send
berseliusQuote Reply
Josh,
Because David Ross was next.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
#meats
berseliusQuote Reply
Why the fuck are you running on cespedes with one out
SitrickQuote Reply
Walking Ross? Wow.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Woof.
At least Javy is good.
SitrickQuote Reply
Fixed.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Ross, then Lester.
uncle daveQuote Reply
Because David Ross and Jon Lester.
ceruleanQuote Reply
At least they tied it up and made Harvey throw some high stress pitches.
PerkinsQuote Reply
If it were the middle of the order coming up, I’d hate the send. As is, it was probably their best chance.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
I get it but still, was pretty clear it wasn’t going to be close.
berseliusQuote Reply
I really hate the idea of the DH in the NL. But having Lester on the team makes me think it wouldn’t be too bad.
ceruleanQuote Reply
The primary sponsors of this game are dick drugs and cars for guys who take dick drugs.
Wenningtons Gorilla CockQuote Reply
Great hit by Castro. Killed that ball.
But, why the fuck wasn’t he on 3rd base?
dmick89Quote Reply
With 1st and 3rd and Baez stealing 2nd and d’Arnaud airmailing Flores, I tend to agree.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Beats the “I’ve fallen and I can’t get up” sponsorships that FOX had going.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Wow that could have been baaaaaaaaaad.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
God. Damnit.
PerkinsQuote Reply
We gave them 5 outs this inning.
MylesQuote Reply
It sounded like the 2B cut off the ball? Also, I assume Rizzo was on 1B and didn’t run until he knew it was over the guy’s head, which meant Castro would have had to jog until Rizzo took off…
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Rice Cube, Castro watched it out if the box as if it was either a home run or easy out. Still, considering the bad throw home, Castro should have been on 3rd.
That said, I'm not really sure why Ross was pissed off at Castro unless they had the play on and Castro missed the sign.
dmick89Quote Reply
Hey guys…. i brought the coleslaw… Kris Bryant doesn’t get any for that drop last inning.
FonteYESQuote Reply
Damnit. Hits Harvey and he still makes the play.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Fuck you Matt Harvey. Fuck you in the ear.
FonteYESQuote Reply
Harvey had that throwing to first thing down. Cubs pitchers can learn from him.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
http://m.mlb.com/chc/video/topic/94788780/v524034583/nlcs-gm1-castro-ties-the-game-with-double-to-center/?team_id=112
Rice CubeQuote Reply
If he hits a HR, does he still get dinner?
PerkinsQuote Reply
Time to redeem yourself, Kris.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Fucking lucky Harvey.
PerkinsQuote Reply
We’re just gonna get the shit end of babip all night, aren’t we
SitrickQuote Reply
Cubs sure are hitting some hard liners right at people.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
I wonder if the crowd chanting “Harvey” will unnerve him. (dying laughing)
ceruleanQuote Reply
dmick89,
I had some thoughts after watching the replay a couple times…
https://twitter.com/CubicSnarkonia/status/655560083787661312
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Perkins,
No, he gets to go to bed without dinner tonight. That will teach him to Play The Game The Right Way (TM)
FonteYESQuote Reply
Rizzo probably should just stand on the plate next inning.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Would be nice if tbs had a better angle on the play.
dmick89Quote Reply
Those were two really nice plays.
ceruleanQuote Reply
God TBS blows
Wenningtons Gorilla CockQuote Reply
God. Damn. It.
PerkinsQuote Reply
I hate the Mets
MylesQuote Reply
Dammit.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Not that Lester has pitched poorly, but I feel like starting Arrieta would have been a better move.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Jesus. That was crushed.
dmick89Quote Reply
Can we take lester out yet?
JoshQuote Reply
Perkins,
I agree. Also, no Ross in the lineup.
dmick89Quote Reply
Myles,
Yeah pretty much. I was hoping the Dodgers would win.
JoshQuote Reply
On the plus side, at least Maddon can probably PH for Ross the next time he’s due to come up. Gotta think that’s it for Lester.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Late runs, please.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Precisely. How about a crooked number?
ceruleanQuote Reply
Oh for crying out loud.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
FonteYES,
At least Rizzo can have dinner.
PerkinsQuote Reply
BABIP hates the Cubs tonight.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Ugh I hope Rizzo is okay
JoshQuote Reply
Hey, good luck for a change!
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
BABIP finally smiles on the Cubs!
PerkinsQuote Reply
We’ll take it.
ceruleanQuote Reply
This would be a great time for a Javybomb.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Fuck! Shit! Piss!
umbraQuote Reply
Fucking Ross is worthless
WaLiQuote Reply
The Mets are really committed to ignoring Harvey’s doctor’s orders.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Have to hope they’ll have better luck against Thor, given how many times he warmed up before actually pitching the other night.
PerkinsQuote Reply
WaLi,
That’s Montero.
ceruleanQuote Reply
How do you leave Lester in for the 7th? The bullpen is an asset Maddon. Why PH LaStella instead of Montero? 3 runs behind is so much different than 1.
ChrisQuote Reply
Schwarber!
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Okay, so a couple more HRs and the Cubs are right back in this thing.
PerkinsQuote Reply
SCHWARBER
dmick89Quote Reply
More late runs, please.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
What the frizzo
JoshQuote Reply
Castro
Soler
Montero
If Castro gets on base, Berry PR, let fireworks ensue
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Pitching: Richard.
WHO?
JoshQuote Reply
Familia is good at this whole sports shindig
FonteYESQuote Reply
So…. why not Rondon or Strop here….
FonteYESQuote Reply
cerulean,
I know. Was just bitching about Ross because he had to get pinch hit for.
WaLiQuote Reply
Josh,
Obligatory LOOGY
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Ah. I thought maybe you weren’t paying attention, in which case, fucking Ross.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Rizzo the Rat,
I suppose. I mean. Ah i see Richard for the lefty and then he brings in Cahil. I see what you did there Joe you clever bastard.
FonteYESQuote Reply
I, for one, welcome our new Good Trevor Cahill overlord.
What kind of black devil magic did Thoyer have to perform for Cahil to magically become good?
FonteYESQuote Reply
A 3 run 9th would be a very good strategy for the Cubs.
dmick89Quote Reply
Three late runs, please.
ceruleanQuote Reply
FonteYES,
Bosio will provide.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Delete
FonteYESQuote Reply
These ain’t the Sox.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Don’t tell me what to do.
FonteYESQuote Reply
Rice Cube,
Why PR when he wouldn’t even be the tying run?
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
That inside first strike was quite the gift.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Shut me right up
FonteYESQuote Reply
Montero did not make an out.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Oh good catcher is playing now… perhaps he should play every game… or something
FonteYESQuote Reply
BABIP really hates the Cubs.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Whelp… can’t win em all. Wish Maddon woulda pulled lester and gone with Cahill/Wood earlier.
Smell ya later folks.
FonteYESQuote Reply
Maybe go with Montero catching Lester in game 5, Joe. Ross is as bad at hitting as he is good at coaching.
PerkinsQuote Reply
Unsustainably so.
ceruleanQuote Reply
Rizzo the Rat,
Was thinking of staying out of DP but it doesn’t matter anymore.
Rice CubeQuote Reply
Perkins,
And its not even like Ross is superior defensively. Montero is by far the better framer. This isn’t like with the Red Sox where Varitek could not catch for Wakefield. Come on Joe, you’re better than that.
FonteYESQuote Reply
Yeah, knuckleballers are challenging enough to need personal catchers. The only thing difficult about catching Lester is his inability to stop the running game, but this is the Mets we’re talking about.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
Tough loss, but I only had one or two nit picky complaints. Thought that Castro send was dumb and would have pulled Lester earlier, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. The Cubs had their chances in the seventh and eighth and just didn’t get them in. At least this isn’t like losing to the Phillies, Harvey was dealing today.
*inserts boilerplate strike zone complaints*
berseliusQuote Reply
berselius,
Hey B! Long time no talk. Whats up?
FonteYESQuote Reply
My main complaint is that they didn’t score more runs. Strategy-wise it was a pretty boring game.
Rizzo the RatQuote Reply
He was. That’s the only reason I’m not more upset. He was outstanding tonight. Not sure why the Mets brought him back out in the 8th, but whatever. Still think Castro should have been at 3rd, but in the end, it wouldn’t have mattered. Would have taken Lester out sooner. I’d probably have taken him out after the 5th. Definitely after the 6th. They just got beat. Even if Montero was in there (which he should have been), they’d have gotten beat.
Schwarber has as much raw power as any player ever at his age. Bryant has tremendous power, but Schwarber has now hit 20 home runs at the MLB level in half as many plate appearances as Bryant has (27 HR).
dmick89Quote Reply
FonteYES,
Things are good if crazy busy. I moved to New Mexico a year or so ago, and am enjoying living in the mountains. Who knew that NM wasn’t just all roadrunner/breaking bad style desert?
berseliusQuote Reply
B, Dmick, Perk, Phil, Manu..
This maybe the best thing I’ve ever read
Enjoy
FonteYESQuote Reply
FTFY
ceruleanQuote Reply
Dread of night. Dread of not-night.
Suburban kidQuote Reply
Tonight is kind of a must-win game.
dmick89Quote Reply
But there is a lot of blue meth, right?
dmick891Quote Reply
dmick891,
From what I hear, heroin is the big winner out where I live.
berseliusQuote Reply
Hastily assembled shit
http://obstructedview.net/nlcs-game-2-thread/
berseliusQuote Reply