As we start to turn the corner to the final stretch of the baseball regular season, people’s thoughts inevitably turn towards the MVP and Cy Young discussions. We’ve already seen at least one HOT TAEK in that regard, and I’m sure there will be plenty more. In the NL, however, there seems to be a 2-horse race between Kris Bryant and Corey Seager. I’d like to run down the top 10 candidates for NL MVP, and then focus on those 2.
Daniel Murphy leads the NL in slugging by nearly 50 points. Inexplicably, he’s been the best pure hitter in the NL with a 159 wRC+, and only a surprising lack of walks (especially for someone with his power numbers) puts a slight damper on his offensive ability. That said, he’s a butcher in the field.
Nolan Arenado is having a Larry Walker year – that is, Coors is making him look like this offensive juggernaut. 1.042 OPS at Coors, .745 OPS everywhere else. He’s a great defender, probably better than Bryant, but you almost have to hit .360/.440/.620 to get MVP consideration from Colorado. It’s just too easy to hit there.
Freddie Freeman is the best player in the league that over 75% of casual baseball fans have never once heard of. He’s hitting .288/.384/.543 for the worst team in baseball, and he improved his hard hit ball% to near the league high. He’s probably not the best 1B in the league this year, but he deserves a passing mention in hack MVP articles like this one.
Anthony Rizzo has basically been Freddie Freeman this year (.290/.394/.563) but a little better everywhere. That makes Freddie Freeman Pareto-suboptimal. Rizzo gets the standard “he’s a 1B” penalty to his MVP case, but he’s (as usual) one of the 5-10 best players in the league.
How’s Andrew Cashner doing?
Matt Carpenter is as annoyingly good as he usually is. He’s played all over for the Cardinals, and would perhaps be the MVP favorite had he played all season, but an injury has put him firmly in second-tier category.
Paul Goldschmidt and Joey Votto both have trinity lines this year (.3xx/.4xx/.5xx). They are so freaking good, as they are every year. This might be the first year where I can say I’d rather have Rizzo then Pauly G, but it’s super close. Votto struggled early this year, and then decided he was still the best hitter alive.
I’d be remiss not to include Clayton Kershaw at some point. His injury is the only reason he isn’t the actual favorite to win the MVP this year. It’s a legit argument to never vote for a pitcher for MVP, but he was having the best year since Pedro and it’s a real bummer he’s not healthy right now.
Those 8 are in some fungible order in competition for the 3rd through 10th slots. You could even put some random guys on there (Wil Myers, Buster Posey, Brendan Crawford) if you want to spice it up a bit. In my mind, though, 1st and 2nd are spoken for. It’s either Seager or Bryant.
The two batters have different profiles this year. The case for Bryant is that he’s simply the better player offensively.
Bryant: .289/.386/.544, 28 HR, 8 SB, .393 wOBA
Seager: .309/.362/.530, 21 HR, 1 SB, .376 wOBA