So as you know, I had jury duty this week and that was a different experience than my previous ones with the judicial process. I don’t think I’ve ever actually been inside a courtroom before, but the first time I went to jury duty, I sat in a holding room for hours until the clerk told us to go home. The next time I was in Illinois for graduate school when California somehow found me, and I had to call and explain to the court that I was a couple thousand miles away. The one before this one was during the height of the pandemic and the process is that you’re supposed to call the court the night before, and they told me we were excused which was a huge sigh of relief.
It seems like the courthouses I’ve been to look nothing like the ornate buildings with the Corinthian columns and the triangle roof thing, but rather like repurposed schools, including this one in Richmond even though it was technically the “Superior Court.” The good news is that this time, when I couldn’t escape jury duty (there’s an email to explain hardships but I’m not a very good liar and I honestly had no excuse not to go, and I don’t think “I have to take care of my new dog because he’s lost without me” will work), my job at least would pay me up to a week. I didn’t need the full week though, but still had to drive out to court for a couple days during this drawn out process.
About 70 of us came on the first morning to check in and receive our jury numbers, I happened to be #54 which most likely meant I wouldn’t have to serve on the panel of 12 plus however many alternates California uses. The jury clerk was a goofball who looked like young Ethan Hawke as a porn star and apparently this was his final week so he didn’t really give a shit although he did his job capably. He did the standard announcements to make sure we knew to be on time and be present until the judge excused us, showed a video, and then we waited for almost four hours until we finally were led up to the courtroom.
I kind of liked the diversity of prospective jurors in this pool, and the prosecution were POC (the district attorney was Black and his paralegal was Latino) while the public defender looked like Dog the Bounty Hunter but probably less racist. The judge was a soft-spoken but firm woman who apologized for the court taking forever to get us started. I kind of wish GBTS or Julie or Craig Calcaterra was around to tell me whether I can even tell you passing details about the case after we were all excused (more on that later) but I’ll just keep the story ambiguous to protect the presumed innocent.
Having read a lot of John Grisham novels and a huge fan of the Legal Eagle YouTube channel, I have a passing understanding of the law (probably mostly from watching My Cousin Vinny) but I am definitely not a lawyer. However, the parts about not discussing details of the case outside the court with anyone besides fellow jurors was common sense, and both the DA and the public defender emphasized the terms “impartial” and “presumed innocent” and “reasonable doubt” before the voir dire process.
Before we got to that point though, the judge was able to dismiss jurors who had mistakenly received a summons despite no longer living in the county, and there was one guy who was cussing out the judicial system and told the judge he was a convicted felon so she was silent for a few seconds to process WTF just happened before dismissing him while I cracked up behind my mask (I mean, I was going to be stuck in a room with a bunch of people for hours, of course I’m wearing a mask!). The judge then moved on to deal with hardship cases, i.e. excessive travel, no jury duty paid time off, etc. This was done in the half hour before we had the lunch break.
Upon return, the judge spent 15 minutes with the hardship cases and dismissed five jurors, then we were all seated randomly except the unlucky first 18, with 12 in the main pit and six alternates (I guess). I thought the DA and the public defender both did a good job, and the DA explained reasonable doubt pretty well while the public defender emphasized the presumption of innocence. Then they did voir dire which was super interesting, where each of the first 18 were grilled (nicely, actually) about their implicit biases and whether they could put their past experiences aside and render a verdict consistent with the applicable law.
At this point I should probably say this was a domestic violence criminal charge and that the defendant was in presence, but based on what I could tell, the DA was unlikely to have the alleged victim testify, while the public defender kept emphasizing the Fifth Amendment, so if this had gone to trial it would have been based on third party eyewitnesses and not the directly affected parties, which would probably have also been interesting to see how the cases would have proceeded. The public defender was very good at explaining how invoking the Fifth is just a protection against self-incrimination and not evidence of guilt, although I suppose when certain ex-Presidents take the Fifth like 500 times in an hour that probably tells you something.
As a staunch opponent of domestic violence and having learned that you should always believe the victim at least to the point of gathering all the facts without condemnation, I can’t tell you how I would have voted had I been selected, but I think there were plenty of folks in the first 18 who have experienced domestic violence in some form or another and they were obviously very upset by it. One woman kept insisting she couldn’t remember shit (and I was wondering how she even got to court in the first place if she had Dory syndrome), but after the judge and the attorneys conferred, she and the various upset jurors were excused and then we had to adjourn for the day.
The next day was super dumb and could have been an email, as we reported on time but within five minutes of being seated, the judge said the case had been resolved and we could all go home as we were excused. I don’t know what a resolution in this case entails but I hope everyone is okay going forward and gets the help they need. I did get a couple days off work though, so I guess that’s a win?